Chapter 4: St. Augustine, Florida

The investigators travel to St. Augustine, Florida, on the trail of Colin Baxter. Their investigation leads them from clandestine 1920s speakeasies to a rusty steamboat expedition towards Bimini. Underneath the waves, they must explore the sunken remains of a Spanish galleon, La Rosario, and potentially uncover ancient, unfathomable stone ruins on the ocean floor.

Back in town, the mystery deepens with a profaned grave in a muddy cemetery, leading into claustrophobic ghoul tunnels. The investigators must navigate sordid alligator farms and confront a terrifying cannibalistic cult hiding within the dark catacombs of an old Spanish fort, culminating in a blood-chilling ritual room deep underground.